Reese's Peanut Butter Cups with OREO Pieces King Size
Two iconic candy traditions collide in one king-size cup, and the result is the kind of snack discovery that makes you want to immediately tell someone about it.
TL;DR Summary
Pros
- OREO cookie pieces add genuine, lasting crunch that holds up in the filling
- Layered chocolate flavor — milk chocolate shell plus cocoa-forward cookie bits — is more complex than a standard Reese's cup
- King-size format gives you enough of each component in every bite
- Individually wrapped packs keep everything fresh and portion-friendly
- Pack of 24 is excellent value for stocking a snack drawer or baking projects
- The peanut butter–to–cookie ratio feels intentional and well-balanced
Cons
- $60 for the full case is a bulk commitment — not a casual single-bar purchase
- Firmly in indulgent territory; the triple-layer sweetness isn't for the faint of sweet tooth
View Product
Check availability and current pricing
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Price shown ($32.99) reflects what we paid at time of purchase and may differ from current seller pricing.
Extended Observations
Two iconic candy traditions collide in one king-size cup, and the result is the kind of snack discovery that makes you want to immediately tell someone about it.
I'll be honest: when I first heard about Reese's OREO — the search term that apparently brought a lot of people to this product — I assumed it was one of those limited-edition gimmicks that sounds better in a press release than it tastes in real life. I was wrong. These king-size cups are genuinely exciting, the kind of mashup that makes you wonder why it took this long.
The base is classic Reese's: that slightly salty, dense peanut butter filling surrounded by milk chocolate that has just enough sweetness to balance it out. What the OREO pieces add is something I didn't expect — genuine textural contrast. The crunchy cookie bits are distributed throughout the filling, and they hold their crunch even after the cup has been sitting at room temperature. That's an engineering win I appreciate.
From a flavor standpoint, the cocoa notes in the OREO cookie pieces actually amplify the chocolate layer rather than competing with it. You get this layered chocolate experience — the milk chocolate shell, then the darker, slightly bitter cookie crumble — all wrapped around the peanut butter center. It's a more complex bite than a standard Reese's cup, and I mean that as a compliment.
The king-size format (4 cups per pack) is the right call here. You want enough surface area to actually register all three components in a single bite. A mini version of this would lose the whole point. The pack of 24 is also a smart pantry play — individually wrapped packs mean they stay fresh and are easy to portion out for a movie night, a snack drawer, or, let's be real, a baking project. Chopped up and folded into a brownie batter? Absolutely yes.
The only thing worth noting is that a $60 case is a commitment — this is bulk buying territory, not an impulse grab. And if you're the kind of person who prefers a cleaner, less sweet snack, the combination of milk chocolate, cookie, and peanut butter is unapologetically indulgent. But if you're here for that, these deliver at a level that earns the hype around the Reese's OREO collab completely.
Our Verdict
Two iconic candy traditions collide in one king-size cup, and the result is the kind of snack discovery that makes you want to immediately tell someone about it.
Buy NowAffiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you
What customers are saying
8 reviewsAs someone who adores Reese's products, I found these King Size cups with OREO Pieces to be a significant step up. The blend of smooth milk chocolate, velvety peanut butter, and those crispy OREO cook...
Can't get enough of these.
This flavor pairing is unmatched. The portion size is exactly right.
Arrived in excellent shape and faster than anticipated. Nothing to fault.
The flavor blend is truly scrumptious.
Discussion
0 commentsSign in to join the discussion
Sign inNo comments yet. Be the first to share.