Poppy Playtime CatNap Deluxe Plush 14"
CatNap is officially the most unsettling plush to ever earn a permanent spot on my couch — and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. Fourteen inches of eerily accurate, deeply huggable chaos.
TL;DR Summary
Pros
- Officially licensed with faithful character accuracy — CatNap looks exactly right
- High-quality plush fabric that's soft, durable, and doesn't feel cheap
- Holds its shape well thanks to even, firm stuffing
- 14-inch size is satisfying and display-worthy without being unwieldy
- Embroidered facial details are precise and expressive
- Part of a cohesive Smiling Critters line, so it pairs well with other characters
Cons
- Tag is stitched in rather than removable, which may bother display-focused collectors
- 14 inches may feel slightly modest for fans wanting a true statement piece
View Product
Check availability and current pricing
Affiliate link — we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Price shown ($24.99) reflects what we paid at time of purchase and may differ from current seller pricing.
Extended Observations
CatNap is officially the most unsettling plush to ever earn a permanent spot on my couch — and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. Fourteen inches of eerily accurate, deeply huggable chaos.
I want to be upfront about something: I review pet gear for a living, which means I spend a lot of time thinking about what animals actually want versus what humans buy for them. So when I tell you that my cat, Ptolemy — a deeply suspicious tabby who has rejected every toy I've ever purchased — walked straight up to this CatNap plush, sniffed it for a full thirty seconds, and then sat beside it like a colleague, you should understand the gravity of that endorsement.
The Smiling Critters CatNap plush is officially licensed Poppy Playtime merchandise, and it shows. This isn't a rushed cash-in on a popular game — the character design is remarkably faithful, right down to CatNap's drowsy, unsettling expression and the distinctive purple-grey coloring. At 14 inches tall, it hits that sweet spot of being substantial enough to feel like a real collectible but not so large it dominates a shelf. The proportions are spot-on, and whoever handled the embroidery on the face deserves a raise.
The plush construction itself is genuinely impressive. The outer fabric is soft without being that suspiciously slippery microfiber that pills after two washes — this feels more like the kind of plush that holds up over time. The stuffing is even and firm enough that CatNap keeps his shape upright rather than slumping into a sad pile, which matters if you're displaying him rather than just tossing him in a toy bin. For fans of the Smiling Critters lineup specifically, this is the kind of quality that justifies shelf space.
I also appreciate that the officially licensed status isn't just a sticker — the attention to character accuracy suggests real collaboration with the source material rather than a generic approximation. If you've played Chapter 2 of Poppy Playtime and have Feelings about CatNap (and you do, everyone does), this plush captures exactly why. The expression is doing a lot of work here: peaceful, slightly threatening, completely on-brand.
The only thing I'd flag is that the tag is stitched in rather than a hang tag, which is fine for play but slightly annoying if you're a collector who prefers clean presentation. And at 14 inches, it's just a touch small for anyone who wanted something truly display-dominant — though the Dogday variant at a similar price point suggests the whole Smiling Critters line is scaled consistently. Neither of these is a reason to hesitate. CatNap has earned his spot on the couch, and Ptolemy has made his feelings known.
Our Verdict
CatNap is officially the most unsettling plush to ever earn a permanent spot on my couch — and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. Fourteen inches of eerily accurate, deeply huggable chaos.
Buy NowAffiliate link — we may earn a commission at no cost to you
What customers are saying
12 reviewsThe plush arrived in perfect condition matching the product photos exactly. The material is incredibly soft and squishy with outstanding build quality. It's genuinely charming with an impressive desig...
Larger than expected at 14 inches tall, this plush is expertly crafted with evident attention to detail. The vibrant colors remain vivid without any fading, and the fabric feels even softer in person...
Our family adores the smiling critters line, and this plushie exceeded expectations in quality. The colors are vibrant and the size is ideal. I purchased multiple critters from the collection for my d...
Adorable design with solid construction quality.
Exceptional plush that surpassed size expectations—larger is definitely better. The design is impressive and captures the game character authentically. It's a fantastic addition to a growing collectio...
Discussion
0 commentsSign in to join the discussion
Sign inNo comments yet. Be the first to share.